Temperature Changes in the Elastic Properties of the KCl-KBr Solid Solution

A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki
Submitted 1977 | SovietRxiv: ru-197701.12531 | Translated from Russian

Abstract Generated abstract

Elastic properties of single crystals in the KCl and KBr solid solution system were investigated at low temperatures to extend earlier room temperature and high temperature data. Using a pulsed ultrasonic method at 2.5 MHz, longitudinal and transverse wave velocities were measured from 80 to 300 K for several compositions, and the elastic constants, elastic compliances, anisotropy factor, and deviation from the Cauchy relation were calculated. The results show that the constants C11 and C44 increase approximately linearly as temperature decreases, the composition dependence of the elastic constants is negatively nonadditive, and full elastic isotropy is not reached in the studied temperature range, while the C44 to C12 ratio approaches or exceeds unity at low temperatures for KBr rich compositions.

Full Text

Temperature Changes in the Elastic Properties of the KCl—KBr Solid Solution

A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki

(Recommended for publication by the Department of General Physics, TPI)

On single crystals of the KCl—KBr solid solution of various concentrations, the elastic constants were measured by the pulsed ultrasonic method in the temperature range 80—300 K. Regularities in their variation over the investigated temperature interval were established.

Slegel and McKinstry [1] experimentally determined the dependence of the elastic constants of the KCl—KBr solid solution for temperatures above room temperature. In studying the physical properties of solid solutions, the variation of these characteristics in the region of negative temperatures is of no less interest.

In the present work, by the pulsed ultrasonic method [2—7] at a frequency of 2.5 MHz, in the interval 80—300 K, measurements were made of the temperature changes in the elastic properties of single crystals of KCl—KBr solid solutions of various concentrations. The elastic constants $C_{ik}$ and the elastic compliances $S_{ik}$ were determined from the measured values of the propagation velocities of longitudinal elastic waves in the directions $<100>$ and $<110>$ and of transverse waves in the direction $<100>$. The specimens for measurements had dimensions in the sounding direction from 20 to 50 mm. Particular attention was paid to the quality of preparation of the surfaces and to the parallelism of the working faces of the specimens. The specimens intended for measuring the elastic constants $C_{11}$ and $C_{44}$ were made in such a way that the input and reflection surfaces of the ultrasonic vibrations coincided with the crystallographic planes $\{100\}$, while for determining the constant $C_{12}$ additional measurements were required on specimens whose working faces coincided with the crystallographic planes $\{110\}$. Measurements of the propagation velocities of ultrasound in single crystals of the KCl—KBr solid solution of various concentrations were carried out with a DUK-6V pulsed ultrasonic flaw detector with combined-type transducers, according to the procedure described earlier [4—7]. When obtaining the temperature dependences of the ultrasonic propagation velocities, the specimen was glued to the transducer with a mixture consisting of 88% ED-5 epoxy resin and 12% polyethylene polyamine and was placed in a cryostat. In order to prevent cracking of the specimen during the measurements, the cooling rate was kept to no more than 10 K per 1 h. The density of the specimens required for determining the elastic constants was calculated from the measured density values at room temperature and the temperature coefficient of linear expansion [8]. The concentration of the solid solution was measured by ...

by the method of potentiometric titration on samples taken from different parts of the specimen. The concentration of the solid solution of a given composition was taken to be the average value from three measurements. The results of measurements of the coefficients \(S_{ik}\) and the elastic constants \(C_{ik}\), as well as the values calculated from them of the anisotropy factor \(A=\dfrac{2C_{44}}{C_{11}-C_{12}}\) and of the coefficient \(B=\dfrac{C_{44}}{C_{12}}\), characterizing the deviation from the Cauchy relation for different concentrations of the KCl—KBr solid solution and for its pure components KCl and KBr, are placed in Tables 1—VI. The concentration of the solid solutions is expressed in mole percent.

Table 1

100% KCl

\(T^\circ\mathrm{K}\) \(C_{11}\) \(C_{12}\) \(C_{44}\) \(S_{11}\) \(-S_{12}\) \(S_{44}\) \(A\) \(B\)
300 3.989 0.725 0.625 0.2597 0.0452 1.600 0.383 0.862
290 4.028 0.724 0.627 0.2581 0.0443 1.595 0.379 0.866
280 4.060 0.724 0.629 0.2564 0.0433 1.590 0.377 0.869
270 4.095 0.723 0.630 0.2532 0.0426 1.587 0.374 0.871
260 4.130 0.723 0.632 0.2516 0.0418 1.582 0.371 0.874
250 4.155 0.722 0.633 0.2500 0.0412 1.580 0.369 0.877
240 4.195 0.722 0.633 0.2488 0.0404 1.580 0.367 0.878
230 4.230 0.721 0.635 0.2469 0.0395 1.575 0.362 0.881
220 4.268 0.720 0.635 0.2445 0.0390 1.575 0.358 0.882
210 4.300 0.719 0.636 0.2421 0.0380 1.572 0.355 0.885
200 4.330 0.717 0.637 0.2404 0.0373 1.570 0.353 0.889
190 4.360 0.715 0.638 0.2387 0.0365 1.567 0.351 0.892
180 4.390 0.712 0.640 0.2367 0.0355 1.562 0.350 0.899
170 4.415 0.710 0.641 0.2353 0.0350 1.560 0.346 0.902
160 4.450 0.705 0.642 0.2333 0.0340 1.558 0.343 0.910
150 4.490 0.704 0.643 0.2315 0.0335 1.555 0.340 0.913
140 4.522 0.700 0.644 0.2299 0.0330 1.553 0.337 0.920
130 4.542 0.692 0.645 0.2282 0.0320 1.550 0.334 0.930
120 4.575 0.690 0.647 0.2273 0.0310 1.546 0.333 0.937
110 4.600 0.685 0.648 0.2252 0.0305 1.543 0.331 0.946
100 4.640 0.680 0.648 0.2237 0.0295 1.543 0.327 0.953
90 4.670 0.675 0.649 0.2222 0.0290 1.541 0.325 0.961
80 4.700 0.670 0.650 0.2196 0.0280 1.538 0.323 0.969

The elastic constants are in \( \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{dyn}/\mathrm{cm}^{2}\), and the elastic coefficients are in \( \times 10^{11}\ \mathrm{cm}^{2}/\mathrm{dyn}\).

For estimating the accuracy of the measurements, the linear temperature dependences \(C_{11}\), \(C_{44}\), and \(\dfrac{C_{11}-C_{12}}{2}\) were treated by the method of least squares; the following maximum values of the coefficien-

of the variation: 1.15% for \(C_{11}\), 1.78% for \(C_{44}\), and 2.1% for \(\dfrac{C_{11}-C_{12}}{2}\).

A comparison of the results of our measurements with the data of Slagle and McKinstry for room temperatures gives good agreement.

Table 2

74% KCl

\(T^\circ\mathrm{K}\) Elastic constants \(C_{11}\), \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) Elastic constants \(C_{12}\), \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) Elastic constants \(C_{44}\), \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) Elastic coefficients \(S_{11}\), \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn Elastic coefficients \(-S_{12}\), \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn Elastic coefficients \(S_{44}\), \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn \(A\) \(B\)
300 3,782 0,674 0,585 0,2795 0,0423 1,709 0,376 0,868
290 3,819 0,673 0,586 0,2765 0,0414 1,706 0,373 0,871
280 3,856 0,672 0,587 0,2734 0,0406 1,704 0,369 0,873
270 3,888 0,670 0,588 0,2709 0,0399 1,701 0,365 0,878
260 3,917 0,669 0,589 0,2687 0,0392 1,698 0,363 0,880
250 3,948 0,668 0,591 0,2658 0,0385 1,692 0,360 0,885
240 3,984 0,666 0,592 0,2636 0,0378 1,689 0,357 0,889
230 4,017 0,665 0,593 0,2612 0,0371 1,686 0,354 0,892
220 4,029 0,663 0,595 0,2608 0,0366 1,681 0,353 0,897
210 4,082 0,662 0,596 0,2566 0,0358 1,678 0,349 0,901
200 4,109 0,659 0,597 0,2551 0,0353 1,675 0,346 0,906
190 4,140 0,658 0,598 0,2525 0,0346 1,672 0,343 0,909
180 4,171 0,655 0,600 0,2505 0,0340 1,667 0,341 0,914
170 4,198 0,652 0,601 0,2486 0,0334 1,664 0,339 0,922
160 4,222 0,648 0,602 0,2457 0,0328 1,661 0,336 0,929
150 4,262 0,646 0,604 0,2445 0,0322 1,656 0,334 0,935
140 4,292 0,644 0,605 0,2425 0,0315 1,653 0,332 0,940
130 4,323 0,641 0,606 0,2405 0,0308 1,650 0,329 0,945
120 4,340 0,638 0,607 0,2387 0,0303 1,647 0,327 0,951
110 4,380 0,634 0,609 0,2370 0,0297 1,642 0,325 0,960
100 4,409 0,631 0,610 0,2357 0,0291 1,639 0,323 0,967
90 4,434 0,628 0,611 0,2337 0,0284 1,637 0,320 0,973
80 4,472 0,624 0,613 0,2315 0,0278 1,631 0,318 0,983

Analyzing the measurement data, the following conclusions may be drawn:

  1. The elastic constants \(C_{11}\) and \(C_{44}\) of KCl—KBr solid solutions increase linearly with decreasing temperature over the temperature interval studied.

  2. The dependence of the elastic constants \(C_{ik}\) on composition has a negative nonadditivity.

  3. The anisotropy factor \(A\) increases with increasing temperature, while the coefficient

\[ B=\frac{C_{44}}{C_{12}} \]

decreases. Complete isotropy of the elastic properties (\(A=1\)) is not reached by any composition of the solid solution over the temperature interval studied. The coefficient \(B\), on the contrary, at low temperatures of the 80–300 K interval takes a value equal to unity for compositions containing more than 40 mol.% KBr.

Table 3

51% KCl

$T^\circ\mathrm{K}$ Elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm², $C_{11}$ Elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm², $C_{12}$ Elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm², $C_{44}$ Elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm²/dyn, $S_{11}$ Elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm²/dyn, $-S_{12}$ Elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm²/dyn, $S_{44}$ $A$ $B$
300 3,665 0,625 0,558 0,2871 0,0418 1,792 0,367 0,893
290 3,688 0,623 0,559 0,2850 0,0412 1,789 0,365 0,897
280 3,714 0,621 0,560 0,2827 0,0405 1,786 0,362 0,902
270 3,744 0,618 0,561 0,2808 0,0398 1,783 0,359 0,908
260 3,773 0,616 0,562 0,2782 0,0390 1,779 0,356 0,912
250 3,800 0,614 0,563 0,2756 0,0383 1,776 0,352 0,917
240 3,831 0,612 0,564 0,2729 0,0376 1,773 0,350 0,921
230 3,860 0,609 0,566 0,2705 0,0369 1,767 0,348 0,929
220 3,887 0,607 0,567 0,2686 0,0363 1,764 0,346 0,934
210 3,915 0,604 0,568 0,2663 0,0356 1,761 0,343 0,940
200 3,942 0,600 0,570 0,2643 0,0349 1,754 0,341 0,945
190 3,969 0,598 0,571 0,2622 0,0343 1,751 0,339 0,951
180 4,000 0,595 0,572 0,2599 0,0337 1,748 0,336 0,956
170 4,025 0,592 0,573 0,2581 0,0331 1,745 0,334 0,963
160 4,051 0,587 0,574 0,2562 0,0324 1,742 0,331 0,970
150 4,078 0,583 0,575 0,2543 0,0318 1,739 0,329 0,980
140 4,106 0,579 0,576 0,2527 0,0312 1,736 0,326 0,991
130 4,134 0,574 0,578 0,2504 0,0305 1,730 0,325 1,002
120 4,160 0,570 0,580 0,2486 0,0300 1,724 0,323 1,012
110 4,188 0,566 0,582 0,2467 0,0294 1,718 0,321 1,023
100 4,212 0,560 0,583 0,2451 0,0289 1,715 0,319 1,033
90 4,241 0,554 0,585 0,2430 0,0283 1,709 0,317 1,041
80 4,268 0,550 0,586 0,2413 0,0278 1,706 0,315 1,055

Table 4
39.5% KCl

\(T^\circ K\) Elastic constants \( \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{dyn}/\mathrm{cm}^2\): \(C_{11}\) Elastic constants \( \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{dyn}/\mathrm{cm}^2\): \(C_{12}\) Elastic constants \( \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{dyn}/\mathrm{cm}^2\): \(C_{44}\) Elastic coefficients \( \times 10^{11}\ \mathrm{cm}^2/\mathrm{dyn}\): \(S_{11}\) Elastic coefficients \( \times 10^{11}\ \mathrm{cm}^2/\mathrm{dyn}\): \(-S_{12}\) Elastic coefficients \( \times 10^{11}\ \mathrm{cm}^2/\mathrm{dyn}\): \(S_{44}\) \(A\) \(B\)
300 3,630 0,606 0,544 0,2892 0,0414 1,838 0,360 0,897
290 3,669 0,604 0,545 0,2866 0,0407 1,835 0,356 0,902
280 3,691 0,603 0,546 0,2840 0,0400 1,832 0,354 0,905
270 3,714 0,601 0,547 0,2819 0,0393 1,828 0,351 0,910
260 3,744 0,598 0,548 0,2795 0,0386 1,825 0,348 0,916
250 3,777 0,596 0,549 0,2769 0,0380 1,821 0,345 0,921
240 3,811 0,594 0,550 0,2749 0,0373 1,818 0,342 0,926
230 3,829 0,592 0,551 0,2725 0,0366 1,815 0,340 0,931
220 3,846 0,590 0,552 0,2711 0,0359 1,812 0,339 0,936
210 3,883 0,587 0,553 0,2683 0,0354 1,808 0,336 0,942
200 3,908 0,585 0,554 0,2662 0,0347 1,805 0,333 0,947
190 3,945 0,582 0,555 0,2636 0,0341 1,803 0,330 0,953
180 3,960 0,580 0,556 0,2623 0,0335 1,799 0,329 0,958
170 3,986 0,577 0,557 0,2604 0,0329 1,795 0,327 0,965
160 4,020 0,573 0,558 0,2581 0,0324 1,789 0,324 0,973
150 4,042 0,570 0,560 0,2564 0,0317 1,786 0,323 0,982
140 4,071 0,566 0,562 0,2544 0,0311 1,779 0,321 0,993
130 4,093 0,560 0,563 0,2527 0,0304 1,776 0,319 1,005
120 4,114 0,556 0,564 0,2511 0,0299 1,773 0,317 1,015
110 4,133 0,552 0,566 0,2497 0,0293 1,767 0,316 1,026
100 4,159 0,547 0,567 0,2476 0,0288 1,764 0,314 1,036
90 4,193 0,543 0,568 0,2458 0,0282 1,761 0,311 1,046
80 4,217 0,538 0,570 0,2441 0,0276 1,754 0,310 1,060

Table 5
24.5% KCl

$T^\circ\mathrm{K}$ $C_{11}$, elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm$^2$ $C_{12}$, elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm$^2$ $C_{44}$, elastic constants $\times 10^{-11}$ dyn/cm$^2$ $S_{11}$, elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm$^2$/dyn $-S_{12}$, elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm$^2$/dyn $S_{44}$, elastic coefficients $\times 10^{11}$ cm$^2$/dyn $A$ $B$
300 3,546 0,564 0,528 0,2949 0,0405 1,894 0,354 0,936
290 3,575 0,563 0,529 0,2932 0,0398 1,890 0,351 0,939
280 3,603 0,561 0,530 0,2897 0,0390 1,887 0,348 0,947
270 3,629 0,559 0,531 0,2872 0,0383 1,883 0,346 0,950
260 3,655 0,557 0,532 0,2851 0,0377 1,880 0,343 0,951
250 3,679 0,555 0,533 0,2836 0,0372 1,876 0,341 0,960
240 3,709 0,553 0,534 0,2804 0,0364 1,873 0,339 0,965
230 3,733 0,551 0,535 0,2785 0,0358 1,869 0,336 0,971
220 3,754 0,548 0,536 0,2767 0,0352 1,866 0,334 0,978
210 3,784 0,546 0,537 0,2742 0,0346 1,862 0,332 0,984
200 3,811 0,543 0,539 0,2721 0,0339 1,855 0,330 0,993
190 3,838 0,540 0,540 0,2699 0,0333 1,852 0,327 1,000
180 3,865 0,537 0,541 0,2678 0,0327 1,848 0,325 1,007
170 3,891 0,535 0,542 0,2664 0,0322 1,845 0,323 1,013
160 3,916 0,532 0,543 0,2639 0,0316 1,842 0,321 1,021
150 3,936 0,528 0,544 0,2624 0,0310 1,838 0,319 1,031
140 3,961 0,525 0,545 0,2605 0,0305 1,835 0,317 1,038
130 3,982 0,522 0,547 0,2582 0,0299 1,828 0,315 1,048
120 4,016 0,520 0,548 0,2566 0,0294 1,825 0,313 1,054
110 4,041 0,517 0,549 0,2549 0,0289 1,821 0,311 1,062
100 4,061 0,513 0,550 0,2527 0,0283 1,818 0,309 1,072
90 4,093 0,511 0,551 0,2513 0,0279 1,815 0,307 1,078
80 4,115 0,507 0,552 0,2497 0,0274 1,812 0,300 1,088

Table 6

100% KBr

\(T^\circ K\) Elastic constants \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) \(C_{11}\) Elastic constants \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) \(C_{12}\) Elastic constants \(\times 10^{-11}\) dyn/cm\(^2\) \(C_{44}\) Elastic coefficients \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn \(S_{11}\) Elastic coefficients \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn \(-S_{12}\) Elastic coefficients \(\times 10^{11}\) cm\(^2\)/dyn \(S_{44}\) \(A\) \(B\)
300 3.468 0.522 0.507 0.3002 0.0393 1.972 0.344 0.971
290 3.487 0.520 0.508 0.2983 0.0387 1.969 0.342 0.977
280 3.522 0.518 0.509 0.2951 0.0378 1.965 0.339 0.983
270 3.550 0.516 0.511 0.2925 0.0371 1.957 0.337 0.990
260 3.571 0.513 0.512 0.2905 0.0365 1.953 0.335 1.000
250 3.600 0.512 0.513 0.2877 0.0359 1.949 0.332 1.002
240 3.618 0.509 0.514 0.2855 0.0353 1.946 0.331 1.010
230 3.650 0.507 0.515 0.2836 0.0346 1.942 0.328 1.016
220 3.668 0.505 0.516 0.2820 0.0341 1.938 0.326 1.020
210 3.710 0.503 0.517 0.2786 0.0332 1.934 0.322 1.028
200 3.731 0.501 0.518 0.2769 0.0227 1.931 0.321 1.034
190 3.762 0.500 0.519 0.2743 0.0322 1.927 0.318 1.038
180 3.779 0.497 0.519 0.2729 0.0318 1.927 0.316 1.044
170 3.800 0.495 0.520 0.2713 0.0313 1.923 0.315 1.050
160 3.830 0.493 0.521 0.2690 0.0307 1.919 0.312 1.056
150 3.856 0.491 0.522 0.2670 0.0302 1.916 0.310 1.063
140 3.888 0.489 0.523 0.2646 0.0296 1.912 0.308 1.070
130 3.912 0.488 0.524 0.2629 0.0292 1.908 0.306 1.074
120 3.941 0.486 0.525 0.2608 0.0286 1.905 0.304 1.080
110 3.970 0.485 0.526 0.2589 0.0282 1.901 0.302 1.085
100 4.002 0.483 0.527 0.2565 0.0276 1.898 0.300 1.091
90 4.021 0.483 0.527 0.2553 0.0274 1.898 0.298 1.092
80 4.050 0.481 0.528 0.2533 0.0269 1.894 0.296 1.100

REFERENCES

  1. O. D. Slagle, H. A. McKinstry. J. Appl. Phys., 38, 446, 1967.
  2. M. N. Norwood, C. V. Briscoe. Phys. Rev., 112, 45, 1958.
  3. L. K. Galt. Phys. Rev., 73, 1460, 1941.
  4. A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki. Izv. AN SSSR, “Fizika,” 6, 22, 1970.
  5. A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki. FTT, 8, 2247, 1970.
  6. A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki. FTT, 5, 1563, 1970.
  7. A. V. Sharko, A. A. Botaki. FTT, 9, 2701, 1970.
  8. M. S. Ivankina. Dissertation, Tomsk, 1959.

Submission history

Temperature Changes in the Elastic Properties of the KCl-KBr Solid Solution